return to the Home Page

books
movies
DVD's
 
 
 
 
Law and Order: The Complete Third Season (4 out of 5 stars)
Universal/ May 24, 2005

What It’s About: One of the most popular and longest television series ever, Law and Order has created numerous spinoffs, some hits, and recently (Law and Order Trial by Jury) some not so much. This is the third season, most notable for the arrival of Jerry Orbach as Detective Lenny Briscoe, a mid-season replacement for Phil Ceretta (Paul Sorvino). This season has some great episodes including one about the legal aspect of computer crimes, as well as several with great twists and turns like “Manhood” and “Night and Fog”. There 22 episodes in all.
How Does It Look? Pretty much the same as on television. The DVD is released in it’s original TV aspect ratio of 1.33:1, full screen and the picture quality is good although slightly rough and grainy in some parts. Still, the show has always had a bit of a rough edge to it.
How Does It Sound? Good. The sound is Dolby Digital 2.0 which works fine for the show, which is mostly talk. The few action scenes sound a little flat but otherwise it works well.
Extras? Nothing crazy. You get two featurettes and some deleted scenes. One of the featurettes is a Jerry Orbach Tribute and the other is a Jerry Orbach profile with im talking about his character and the series.
Final Verdict: If you’re a Law and Order fan, you’ll love this season as it has great episodes and a solid DVD presentation.

 

The Godfather Part II and III (4 out of 5 stars)
Paramount/ May 24, 2005

What It’s About: Released separately from The Godfather Trilogy, parts 2 and 3 are now available for purchase on their own. The Godfather Part II remains one of the greatest movies of all time, while the third is widely cast as the black sheep of the trilogy and considered a flop, despite its Academy Award nominations.
How Does It Look? Okay. It looks like the same transfer as the trilogy which was a little grainy. A lot of both films takes place indoors in low-lit rooms which don’t come through as beautifully as they should.
How Does It Sound? Super. The 5.1 Dolby Digital mix is likewise the same as the box set and it does justice to both
the action sequences and the whispered conversations. Francis Ford Copolla’s majestic musical score also sounds larger than life.
Extras? Not too many. The big draw here is the commentary by director Francis Ford Coppola on both films that goes through almost the entire length and shows his passion for the film as well as his amiable personality. There is also an original theatrical trailer on both movies.
Final Verdict: It’s nice to see the films available on their own, without a box set that you must purchase if you wanted one or the other. The video transfer could be better but these still remain quality DVDs and the commentary by Coppola is absorbing.

 

Ah, HBO, how we love thee. Six Feet Under: The Complete Third Season is finally on DVD and the set is fantastic. The sound is Dolby Digital 5.1 or Dolby Digital 2.0 and the video is crisp with the dark scenes coming through brilliantly on the screen. Never mind the great writing, compelling characters and complete originality of the show itself. This is a five disc set and extras include "A Birdseye View of the Third Season" : An in-depth interview with show creator Alan Ball including the original HBO trailer, 5 Audio commentaries w/ Alan Ball, writers and directors, Episodic Previews and Recaps, Season 2 Recap and Deleted scenes.

 

The Aviator (4 out of 5 stars)
Warner Bros/ May 24, 2005

What It’s About: A technically stunning film nominated for numerous Academy Awards, The Aviator tells the fascinating story of genius Howard Hughes who, over the course of his life, directed movies, invented planes, dated movie stars, and did all sorts of bizarre things. The best thing about this Scorcese-directed film is Cate Blanchett as Katherine Hepburn who took home the well-deserved Oscar as she steals every single scene she’s in.
How Does It Look? Brilliant. Amazing quality, crisp colour…it doesn’t get much better than this. The high bit rate transfer is excellent.
How Does It Sound? While the surround isn’t used as much as one would think (the subwoofer barely gets a workout) it works for the time period and the soundtrack. The sound is still rich and the Dolby Digital 5.1 is good enough.
Extras? As many as your little heart might want. The Aviator comes in a two-disc set, the first disc being the widescreen presentation of the film; English and French spoken languages; English, French, and Spanish subtitles; thirty-two scene selections; and an audio commentary by Martin Scorsese, film editor Thelma Schoonmaker, and producer Michael Mann. The second disc is completely jam-packed with extras that would take you an entire day to get through. There are five separate menu screens so you can imagine all the stuff on here. It includes:
· Deleted scene: Howard Tells Ava About His Car Accident
· A Life Without Limits: The Making of The Aviator
· The Role of Howard Hughes in Aviation History
· Modern Marvels: Howard Hughes, A Documentary by the History Channel
· The Visual Effects of The Aviator
· The Affliction of Howard Hughes: Obsessive Compulsive Disorder
· The Age of Glamour: The Hair And Makeup of The Aviator
· Costuming The Aviator: The Work of Sandy Powell
· Constructing The Aviator: The Work of Dante Ferretti
· An evening with Leonardo DiCaprio and Alan Alda
· OCD Panel Discussion With Leonardo DiCaprio, Martin Scorsese, and Howard Hughes' Widow Terry Moore
· Still Gallery
· Scoring The Aviator: The Work Of Howard Shore
· The Wainwright Family - Loudon, Rufus and Martha

Final Verdict: A good movie with a spectacular DVD presentation. While Scorcese failed to make an astounding film, it remains a cinematic force and all the extras make for some fascinating and educational watching.

 

New Fox Collector’s Editions (5 out of 5 stars)
Fox/ May 24, 2005

What It’s About: Fox has released three of its most recent and popular movies, Man on Fire, The Day After Tomorrow and I, Robot in All-Access Two-Disc Special Collector’s Editions…and they’re cool. Man on Fire was a fantastic Denzel Washington film where he tries to save nine-year-old Pita Ramos (Dakota Fanning) when she is kidnapped. In I, Robot, Will Smith plays his usual cop with a sarcastic sense of humour role, except this time it’s in the future. The Day After Tomorrow is a great disaster flick about a new Ice Age happening in New York City. It became all that much more fascinating when scientists confirmed that it could indeed happen some day.
How Does It Look? They all look spectacular (these are, after all, Fox Special Collector’s Editions). This is an anamorphic transfer with a wide, 2.13:1 screen dimension which captures most of the films original aspect ratios.
How Does It Sound? The choices for the English track are Dolby Digital 5.1 and DTS 5.1, with the DD 5.1 sounding terrific. These are big blockbuster movies and they give you that big, big sound. The bass is deep, the dynamics are strong, the front-channel stereo spread is wide, and the directionality in all five channels is impressive. All of the surrounding effects and sounds: gunfire, explosions, flying debris, voices, the usual, are perfectly clear and put you right in the middle of the movie.
Extras? Each two-disc set contains enough to keep you busy for longer than it would take you to watch the movie:
Man on Fire includes:
· Commentary by Director Tony Scott
· Commentary by Production - Lucas Foster, Brian Helgeland, Dakota Fanning.
· Vengeance is Mine: Reinventing “Man On Fire” Documentary: Twenty Year Odyssey, The Business of Kidnapping, Caught in the Crossfire, City of God, Fire and Passion.
· Deleted Scenes (with optional commentary by Tony Scott)
· Pita's Abduction: Pita’s Abduction - Multi-Angle Sequence (with optional commentary by Tony Scott), Pita's Abduction -Tony Scott’s Storyboards, Pita's Abduction - Script Excerpt
· Photo Gallery
· Music Video: "Oye Como Va"
· Trailers and TV Spots
I, Robot includes:
· Commentary by director Alex Proyas and screenwriter Akiva Goldsman
· Commentary by production designer Patrick Tatopolous, editor Richard Learoyd, visual effects supervisor John Nelson, associate producer John Kilkenny, animation supervisor Andrew Jones, and visual effects supervisor Brian Van't Hul
· Commentary by composer Marco Beltrami with isolated score
· Comprehensive four-hour interactive tour
· "Days Out of Days" production diaries
· CGI and design featurettes
· "Sentient Machines" (robotic behavior)
· "Three Laws Safe": conversations about sci-fi and robots
· "The Filmmakers' Toolbox" (VFX how-to clues)
· Deleted scenes and alternate ending
The Day After Tomorrow includes:
· Commentary by director/cowriter Roland Emmerich and producer Mark Gordon
· Commentary by cowriter Jeffrey Nachmanoff, director of photography Ueli Steiger, editor David Brenner, and production designer Barry Chusio
· Deleted scenes with optional commentary
· Storyboard and concept art galleries
· Behind-the-scenes production documentary
· Pre- and post-production featurettes
· "The Forces of Destiny" scientific documentary
· Interactive audio demo
· Theatrical teaser and trailers
Final Verdict: If you’re a fan of these movies and like DVD extras, great picture quality and awesome sound, you’re just the Collector these editions are looking for.

 

Pooh’s Heffalump Movie (4 out of 5 stars)
Disney/ May 24, 2005

What It’s About: Teaching kids about the fear of the “other”, Pooh’s Heffalump Movie is coated with all the honey Pooh movies usually are and unlike Shrek or The Incredibles, have very little to offer anyone over the age of seven. But the little ones will love this movie and learn a great lesson about not judging things before you know what they are. When Pooh, Piglet, Rabbit and the others in the Hundred Acre wood hear odd noises they are afraid and concoct all sorts of possibilities. But the sounds end up being an adorable Heffalump named Lumpy. So say it with me children…”First impressions aren’t always true…”
How Does It Look? It’s very colourful. This film was in theatre release so that helps with the picture and it is widescreen and enhanced for 16x9 televisions. Still, the animation is nothing to die over so it remains a little lacking.
How Does It Sound? Great. The DVD contains Dolby Digital 5.1 which is more than enough for this animated kid-flick.
Extras? A few plus DVD-ROM features like printable coloring pages and a Rumpledoodle Recipe:
· Welcome to the Family, Lumpy
· Hide 'n Seek with Roo and Lumpy - Set-Top Game
· Disney's Song Selection
· DVD-ROM extras
Final Verdict: The kids will love it, they’ll learn a valuable lesson and you might even find yourself charmed by a Heffalump.

 

Who doesn't sneak a few minutes of The Golden Girls when the pass a rerun on television? We're all guilty and for good reason: it's darn funny. So rejoice, hidden fans, The Golden Girls: The Complete Second Season has arrived on DVD and you can watch it whenever you like without penalty. The whole thing. All 26 episodes. You can also take the Trivia Challenge and find out if you're as wise as Sophia or clueless as Rose? Three discs, full screen with Dolby Digital Mono Sound.

 

Scrubs: The Complete First Season (5 out of 5 stars)
Buena Vista/ May 17, 2005

What It’s About: One of the funniest and most intelligent comedies on television today, Scrubs takes place at Sacred Heart Hospital where you may not want to get treated but would be a very fun place to hang out. Starring Zach Braff as J.D. the goofy, sensitive and kind of weird resident, the show has a great cast of characters including Donald Faison as Turk, Judy Reyes as his Carla, Neil Flynn as the crazy Janitor and our favourite, John C. McGinley as Perry Cox, the gruff doctor with great one-liners and a deep deep deep down heart of gold.
The first season had the new medical residents just starting to learn the ropes. The look is different from other sitcoms as it is shot with a single camera and without an audience or laugh track. As funny as it is, the show also has some serious moments (allowed since there is no audience to laugh, awww, or coo) and one of the most poignant episodes in this season is “My Old Lady” where the residents lose their first patient. The set comes with three discs and all 24 episodes.
How Does It Look? The show is present in 1:33:1 aspect ration and a full-screen format. It looks better than on TV but it’s not incredibly crisp.
How Does It Sound? Only Dolby Digital 2.0 is available but it gets the job done. Everything sounds clear and well-mixed.
Extras? Quite a few. They are mixed in throughout the discs instead of the usual all on the last disc or separate extras disc:
· Newbies - A retrospective on the actors before they were cast
· The Doctor Is In - one on one with Zach Braff
· Not Just Another Medical Show - making-of featurette
· Favorite Moments - cast and crew on their favorite episodes
· Alternate Lines: A Second Opinion - shows the cast's unique ability to improvise
· Audio Commentaries with creator and cast
· Deleted Scenes
· Outtakes
· "Superman" Music Video
Final Verdict: An amazing show with a great package. We look forward to more seasons.

 

Kinsey (4 out of 5 stars)
Fox Searchlight/ May 17, 2005

What It’s About: Let’s talk about sex, baby in this critically acclaimed flick about Alfred Kinsey (Liam Neeson) a man completely consumed with the scientific side of human sexuality. When he realizes that most of what passes for sexual education consists of propaganda and rumour, he decides to teach his own course for married couples.
Realizing how little is known and how much people want to learn (his class is standing room only) he starts his research and asks people questions about their sexual behaviour. He is encouraged by his wife (Laura Linney) but as with a sexual matters, ends up in a little bit of a controversy. This movie was slammed even before it was made but it succeeds in portraying Kinsey in a fair manner, simply showing his life and what he did without passing judgement.
How Does It Look? Not bad. The DVD is presented in 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen and while it looks quite soft, that is due to its indie roots. The colour is vibrant and the transfer is free of any imperfections. English DTS and Dolby Digital 5.1 audio, plus French and Spanish Dolby Stereo
How Does It Sound? Awesome, actually. Although unnecessary since the film is 90 percent dialogue, Kinsey comes in English DTS and Dolby Digital 5.1 audio, plus French and Spanish Dolby Stereo. Completely centre channel driven, the sound is crisp, clear and free of any distortion. You can hear every single word.
Extras? There are two versions of this disc, a two-disc special edition and a regular release. The first disc of the Special Edition is the same as the regular release. The only extra it features is the full-length audio commentary by writer/director Bill Condon.
The special edition comes with these extras:
· The Kinsey Report: Sex on Film
· 20 deleted scenes plus original ending with optional commentary by writer/director Bill Condon
· Gag reel
· Sex Ed. at the Kinsey Institute
· Interactive sex questionnaire

Final Verdict: A fascinating movie with a good DVD transfer. If you like extras, splurge on the Special Edition.

 

Entourage (4 out of 5 stars)
Warner Home Video/ May 10, 2005

What It’s About: It’s exactly what you expect from an HBO show: quality, smart writing, great characters and an addiction to watching it every week. Entourage offers all that, plus constant laughs. In our opinion, the best way to catch an HBO show is on DVD, where you can watch the episodes in order and for however long you want (make it a marathon). The show follows Vincent Chase (Adrian Grenier) a rising Hollywood heartthrob and his constant posse of friends. The entourage includes Kevin Connoly as Eric, the good guy that Vincent always turns to for advice and doing his dirty work, Johnny Drama, Vincent’s less attractive, B-list actor brother played by Kevin Dillion, Matt Dillon’s less-attractive, B-list actor brother in real life. And we can’t forget Turtle (Jerry Ferrara) the guy who constantly wants to spend money and meet chicks. The best character is the agent played by Jeremy Piven, who drops the f-bomb every second word and has some of the funniest lines in the show.
Unfortunately there are only eight half-hour episodes making up the entire season, which is a great disappointment. We hoped HBO would make it up with extras but…well, read on.
How Does It Look? Great. The constant shift from sunny outdoors to dark clubs and parties creates no problems and the picture remains crisp and clear throughout. We would have liked to have seen a widescreen transfer but all we get is a full screen 1.33: aspect ratio.
How Does It Sound? The Dolby Digital 2.0 audio track is adequate, although we would have liked a 5.1 mix. There is some great music on the show and it could have used a better sound. Still it works and the sound is crisp and clear.
Extras? Not much happening here at all:
· Commentary by creator-executive producer Doug Ellin and executive producer Larry Charles on the episodes "Entourage (Pilot)", "Busey and the Beach," and "New York"
· Behind-the-scenes interviews with cast and crew
Final Verdict: Only eight episodes but they’re great ones. The DVD set is quality and we can’t wait for season two.

 

The trend of old shows resurfacing on DVD continues and Quantum Leap: The Complete Third Season arrives on DVD. How cool was Scott Bakula travelling through time and taking on all these different personas. In this season he becomes a Navy SEAL, a bounty hunter, and beauty pageant contestant and a rock star. His holographic pal Al (Dean Stockwell) with an attitude is back as well and the entire season is surprisingly super-entertaining. We just wish they weren't double-sided DVDs, we hate those.

In Good Company (4 out of 5 stars)
Universal/ May 10, 2005

What It’s About: In the corporate world no one is safe and when poor 51-year-old Dan Foreman (Dennis Quaid) gets demoted at work the same day he finds out his wife is pregnant, he thinks it can’t get any worse. Then in walks his new 26-year old boss, Carter (Topher Grace). That’s pretty bad. When he finds out Carter has started sleeping with his 18-year-old daughter Alex (Scarlett Johansson) it pretty much takes the cake.
The best thing here is Quaid’s performance which is subtle, hysterical and brilliant. The plot isn’t really the main thing of the film, instead it’s the relationship between the characters and the way they react to human hardship and weakness. But through and through this is a comedy with some wonderfully funny moments.
How Does It Look? Super. The widescreen anamorphic transfer is crisp, clean and the colours are brilliant.
How Does It Sound? Just fine. This is a talkie movie so super sound isn’t necessary but the Dolby Digital 5.1 is always a great thing.
Extras? You get your basics which, frankly are all you need here:
· Commentary with Topher Grace and the Director Paul Weitz
· Deleted Scenes
· 2 Featurettes
Final Verdict: A funny and touching film that slipped under people’s radar and is definitely worth watching.

 

Joan of Arcadia: The First Season (5 out of 5 stars)
Paramount/ May 10, 2005

What It’s About: When the Girardi family moves to small town Arcadia from a big city, strange things start to happen. Middle child Joan is unhappy and getting into trouble at school. One day a cute boy tells her he’s God and wants her to do some favours for him. Frankly, we would have Maced him but Joan (after an initial hesitation) buys it and joins in God’s game (or plan or what not).
Surprisingly, this show isn’t as schmaltzy as it seems and each episode gets progressively more and more interesting. John Ritter’s son, Jason Ritter, does an amazing job as Joan’s older brother who is confined to a wheelchair.
How Does It Look? Great. The people at Paramount made this widescreen anamorphic 1.78:1, which is unusual for TV on DVD and an amazing thing. No blurriness or grainy picture. The colours are great and although the night scenes are a tad too dark the DVD transfer here is still superb. And no commercials is always a great thing.
How Does It Sound? Fine. The sound is Dolby Digital 2.0 surround, and since we’re not looking at an action movie, it’s enough.
Extras? A nice assortment that includes:
o Available Audio Tracks: English (PCM Mono)
o Deleted Scenes
o Audio commentaries
o Exclusive Featurettes
Final Verdict: A show you may have passed by when it first came out, Joan of Arcadia is definitely worth catching up with on DVD and this set is the perfect way to do so.

 

The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou (2 out of 5 stars)
Touchstone/ May 10, 2005

What It’s About: Bill Murray attempts to win the Oscar he lost for Lost in Translation in this Wes Anderson film. Unfortunately, it doesn’t quite gel together. Internationally famous oceanographer Steve Zissou (Murray) and his team are after the mysterious Jaguar Shark.
The shark killed Zissou’s partner while they were filming a documentary. An impressive cast exists here including Owen Wilson, Cate Blanchette, Angelica Huston, Willem Dafoe, Jeff Goldblum and more. Although there are some good laughs, the movie becomes a little bit of a snoozefest and not even Murray can save it.
How Does It Look? Incredible. This DVD boasts a new high-definition digital transfer that was approved by Wes Anderson himself and is enhanced for widescreen televisions and has a 2.35:1 aspect ratio. The colour is spectacular and the underwater sequences jump off the screen. Amazing.
How Does It Sound? Stellar. Includes both Digital 5.1 and DTS sound. It’s crisp and clean and every underwater bubble comes through as perfection.
Extras? You bet. This two-disc special edition comes with a case that holds both discs and are they ever packed with stuff:
· Commentary by Wes Anderson and co-writer Noah Baumbach
· "This Is an Adventure," a documentary by Antonio Ferrera, Albert Maysles, and Matthew Prinzing chronicling the production of the movie
· "Mondo Monda," an Italian talk show featuring an interview with Wes Anderson and Noah Baumbach, with host Antonio Monda
· New video interview with composer and Devo member Mark Mothersbaugh
· Ten complete video performances of David Bowie songs in Portuguese by Brazilian recording artist and actor Seu Jorge (Pelé dos Santos)
· Intern video journal by actor and real-life intern Matthew Gray Gubler (Intern #1)
· Multiple interviews with the cast and crew with behind-the-scenes footage
· Ten deleted scenes
· Behind-the-scenes photos and original artwork from the film
· Theatrical trailer
· A fold-out insert featuring a cutaway of the Belafonte, with Eric Anderson's original illustrations, and a conversation with Wes and Eric conducted in 2005
Final Verdict: A so-so movie with a magnificent DVD presentation.

 

12 Monkeys: Special Edition (4 out of 5 stars)
Universal/ May 10, 2005

What It’s About: Brad Pitt actually looks unattractive in this sci-fi flick about a man (Bruce Willis) who is sent back in time to save human kind from a deadly virus that has forced them into soggy underground communities in the future. He comes across a mental patient (Pitt) and a psychiatrist (Madeleine Stowe) who may hold the answers he needs. 12 Monkeys has become a bit of a classic now and one of the best things is Willis’ performance which is very understated and convincing. A little dark and a little weird, it’s still quite enjoyable.
How Does It Look? Great. Universal has digitally remastered the picture and all the underground and dark scenes look fantastic. 1.85:1 anamorphic Widescreen.
How Does It Sound? Quite good. We would have liked to have seen DTS sound with a special edition but the Dolby 5.1 holds its own with the booming sci-fi sound in the flick.
Extras? Not as many as you’d expect but the usual:
· Feature commentary with director Terry Gilliam & producer Charles Roven
· The hamster factor & other tales of 12 Monkeys
· Theatrical trailer
· 12 Monkeys archives
Final Verdict: A very cool movie classic with an improved DVD package.

 

It's nice to watch a show on occasion that is more uplifting than depressing, involves no Law or Order or any CSI members dissecting corpses. Touched by an Angel fits that bill perfectly and it gained a large following by bringing a message of hope and faith to its millions of viewers. The Second Season is now out on DVD and features Monica (Roma Downey) maturing as a caseworker and needing the supervision of Tess (Della Reese). John Dye is Andrew, the Angel of Death but not in the way we're used to. A great show to catch when you're feeling like the world is an awful place.

Pocahontas: Tenth Anniversary Edition (4 out of 5 stars)
Disney/ May 3, 2005
What It’s About: One of Disney’s movies that didn’t quite make it into the Lion King etc. legacy, Pocahontas is the semi-historical account of a Native woman who falls for English settler Captain John Smith. While the setting and spirit of the movie are accurate, it’s imposiible not to get sidetracked by the complete Disney-fying of the rest of the story.
Pocahontas and John Smith were not even remotely close to that attractive in real life; she was actually around 12 years old. Still, the movie succeeds on different levels and does bring some awareness to the plight of the Native people with the arrival of the English. This is the tenth anniversary edition so Disney has added a new song and loaded the set with special features.
How Does It Look? Disney always does an incredible job remastering and restoring their animated films and Pocahontas is no exception. Incredibly vibrant and clear, the images are perfection. It has also been enhanced for 16x9 televisions.
How Does It Sound? The sound was also restored and remastered and the Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound makes you feel like you’re in the forest. Includes French and Spanish language tracks.
Extras? Holy-moly, this two-disc set is packed to the gills. There are two versions of the film: the original theatrical release and the new 10th Anniversary Edition which includes the song "If I Never Knew You", sung by Mel Gibson with all-new animation, Commentary by producer James Pentecost, directors Eric Goldberg & Mike Gabriel, "Follow your Heart" & "Art Project" Set-Top Games, and a music video. The second disc includes "The Making of Pocahontas" featurette, Production: Early Presentation Reels, Storyboards, Production Progression, Nine Deleted Scenes, "The Music of Pocahontas, The Release: The Premiere, Trailers, Multi-Language Reel, Pubicity Gallery, and The Design Galleries.
Final Verdict: Not one of Disney’s best but still a great animated movie, in an outstanding 10th Anniversary Edition with Extras galore!

Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Phantom of the Opera (3 out of 5 stars)
Warner Brothers/ May 3, 2005

After nearly twenty years, Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera makes the jump from stage to screen, courtesy of director Joel Schumacher. Fans of the opera, which has been playing around the world non-stop for nearly two decades, should be happy with the result, aside from the small but vocal contingent who still wanted Sarah Brightman and Michael Crawford to reprise their roles on the big screen. This was unlikely given the split between Webber and Brightman and the fact that Crawford is nearing retirement age. Instead, Schumacher went the other route. Once he cast Emily Rossum as Christine, he made all the characters younger. Rossum, who sang at the Met when she was a child, wasn't even eighteen when Phantom was filmed. The younger stars actually make the story work better, given some of its naïve and cheesy character arcs.
Nobody has ever accused Schumacher of restraint, and he goes all out visually in the film. The look of the film is probably the best aspect of the entire movie. The sets are opulent, ornate, even gaudy to the point of excess. The entryway into the Paris Opera Populaire, with its sweeping staircase is magnificent. He vividly stages the dance numbers with dozens of people, all costumed elaborately. The singing is decent, with Rossum's good vocals offset by amateurish turns by Gerard Butler (who has no classical training) and Patrick Wilson. It's too bad that there is no sense of life given all the production value. The dancing is often reminiscent of a Vogue-era Madonna, and the story remains as it is, a tad on the cheesy side. Again, Schumacher bases the film primarily on Webber's musical, based on the novel by Gaston Leroux. Webber even wrote some original music for the film.
Christine grew up in the Opera, tutored by the Phantom (Butler), who desires her. When reigning diva Carlotta (a hammy Minnie Driver) storms out, Madame Giry (Natasha Richardson) suggests that Christine take her place. The audience loves her, as does the new owner, Raoul (Patrick Wilson), who was also a childhood friend. Much to the Phantom's dismay, Christine and Raoul fall in love. At its heart, Phantom is a love triangle between Christine, Raoul, and the Phantom, but it never works.
It's hard to believe that Raoul and Christine can fall in love so quickly (there is no chemistry between them), or that the Phantom seems so, well, dumb. Christine's young age explains her naivete, but otherwise, as a film, Phantom of the Opera does not work that well. The scale is grander and Schumacher takes advantage of a larger canvas, but he does not adapt the story well enough to the different genre. A bit of melodrama is fine on stage, but on screen it looks silly. Instead, Schumacher overcompensates by pouring forth a lot of energy into the settings and costumes, giving the movie an empty feeling.
The two-disc DVD set comes with Theatrical trailer, explore the Phantom's world in dazzling depth: Behind the Mask - The Story of The Phantom of the Opera, The Making of The Phantom of the Opera in 3 spellbinding acts: Preproduction, The Director, Production, No One Would Listen: additional scene, DVD-ROM PC weblink to the Phantom's online world.

 

National Treasure (2 out of 5 stars)
Walt Disney/ May 3, 2005

It's so easy to make fun of mega-producer Jerry Bruckheimer. All his movies are basically the same. They are action extravaganzas with beautiful women, strapping men, explosions, car chases, one-liners, a score that mixes synthesizers and orchestral music (usually by Trevor Rabin or Hans Zimmer), and most importantly, utterly devoid of thought. Bruckheimer is setting out to entertain, not to make people think. And unfortunately, most people want big and stupid, instead of something worthwhile. National Treasure takes an interesting idea, and then gives it a lobotomy in order to Bruckheimer-ize it. It is a mixture of The Da Vinci Code and Indiana Jones, with treasure hunter (or protector as he prefers) Benjamin Franklin Gates (Nicholas Cage) searching for a legendary hidden treasure amassed over centuries and passed down from the Knights Templars to the Freemasons.
His family carried the secret of the treasure for generations, passing it from father to son. Each generation searched in vain, following clues left by the founding fathers, but only Gates is going anywhere with the clues. The endless search disillusioned his father Patrick (Jon Voight), and the two are now estranged. However, the beginning of National Treasure finds Gates, his quipping sidekick Riley Poole (Justin Bartha), and funder Ian Howe (Sean Bean) discovering a ship buried in the Arctic Circle, and discover a clue that leads them to believe a map is on the back of the Declaration of Independence. The process that Gates goes through to decipher this clue is indicative of National Treasure as a whole. It is completely unbelievable, and laughable at how simplistic everybody distills the material.
Gates and Howe part ways bitterly, and now Gates believes he needs to steal the Declaration in order to protect it from Howe, who only wants the treasure. This leads them to Dr. Abigail Chase (Diane Kruger), who scoffs at their assertions. She later becomes suspicious, and gets caught up in the chase when Gates does manage the impossible. Now, since she's one of the hottest PhDs working for the government, her curiosity for the treasure will allow her to join Gates in his quest, and the two will conveniently fall in love. So National Treasure now turns into multiple chase scenes, with Gates going after the treasure, Howe going after Gates and the treasure, and FBI Agent Sadusky (Harvey Keitel) chasing after Howe, Gates, and the Declaration.
At its core, National Treasure should be a thinking film. It would succeed if these extremely smart people took the time to decipher the clues and actually discover the treasure. Why is there such a rush to get this treasure? It's been successfully hidden for over two centuries. Why is Howe in such a rush? He is already rich to begin with. The leaps that Gates (what an idiotic name) makes are astounding, and work only because the script says so. Nevertheless, National Treasure is entertaining in its own way, by creating a nice fantasy story and imbuing just enough thought behind the plot to make it plausible, and moves quickly enough so people don't have time to think.
The DVD features a multilevel treasure hunt: the more bonus material you find and watch, the more you uncover, Alternate ending with optional director's audio commentary, Deleted scenes with optional director's audio commentary, "National Treasure on Location" making-of featurette, "The Knights Templar" featurette, "Treasure Hunters Revealed" featurette, "Riley's Decode This!" featurette plus 3 puzzling challenges, opening scene animatic with optional director's audio commentary and a Verizon trailer and mobile phone games.

 

Star Trek Enterprise: The Complete First Season (4 out of 5 stars)
Paramount/ May 3, 2005

After Star Trek: The Next Generation, there seemed to be no real hope for Trekkies everywhere. All consequent spinoffs were mediocre and movies bombed. Then came Enterprise. This was a prequel series that predated the original by 150 years. Trekkies were nervous. It was a little different than what they were used to. But Enterprise proved to be a pleasant surprise.
I’m not a Trekkie by any means but I enjoyed watching this series very much. Episodes stayed true to the series and included Vulcans, Klingons Andorians and the Ferengi while also introducing new characters, plotlines and furthering established characters. Captain Jonathan Archer (Scott Bakula) was inherently likeable and his testy relationship with Vulcan Sub-Commander, T'Pol (Jolene Blalock) was very entertaining.
The new DVD set is truly impressive and completely justifies the higher price. Presented in a futuristic metal tin (you expected something different?) it includes seven discs including over two hours of special features. These include seven behind the scenes featurettes like Creating Enterprise, A profile of Scott Bakula: O Captain! My Captain!, Cast Impressions: Season One, Inside Shuttlepod One, Star Trek Time Travel: temporal cold wars and beyond, Enterprise secrets, Admiral Forrest takes centre stage, nearly nine minutes of incredibly funny outtakes and deleted scenes.
Enterprise won’t make it past season four but that’s not reflective of the quality of the show by any means. It’s simply a reflection of a society that would rather watch Extreme Makeover rather than an intelligently-written and original series.

 

Past Reviews:

April ‘05
Beaches
Survivor: The Australian Outback
Sacred Planet
Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events
The Twilight Zone Season Two
Meet the Fockers
Viva La Bam Season Two and Three
Ocean’s Twelve
Hotel Rwanda
Magnum P.I., Knight Rider and The A-Team: The Complete Second Seasons
The West Wing: The Fourth Season
Bad Girls at Valley High
Sideways
Elektra

March ‘05
Kojak
America’s Next Top Model: Cycle One
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead
National Lampoon’s Gold Diggers
Being Julia
Bringing Up Baby
Bridget Jones: The Edge of Reason
Fat Albert
Alfie
Miss Congeniality: Deluxe Edition
The Incredibles
What the Bleep Do We Know?
Dead Birds
Sweet Valley High: Season One
Wonder Woman: Second Season
Friends: The Complete Ninth Season
Felicity: Senior Year
Exorcist: The Beginning
Ladder 49
Hoosiers
Bambi
The Brady Bunch: Season One
Spongebob Squarepants: The Movie
It Happened to Jane

February ‘05
Stripperella: Season One
Seventh Heaven: The Complete Second Season
Malcolm X: Special Edition
Deadwood: The Complete First Season
The Martin Scorsese Collection
Taxi
Miami Vice: Season One
One Tree Hill: The Complete First Season
Ray
Mr. 3000
Mulan II
Charmed: The Complete First Season
Frasier: The Complete Fourth Season
Aladdin II and III Box Set

January ‘05
Friday Night Lights
The Rocky Anthology
Classic Cartoon Favourites
The Village

December '04
Wicker Park
Anchorman
King Arthur
De-Lovely
Thunderbirds
Walt Disney Treasures
Two Brothers
Newlyweds: The First Season
The Ben Stiller Collection
Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement
Frasier: The Final Season
Mary Poppins
The Bourne Supremacy
The Terminal
Christmas Fare DVD Set
Golden Girls: The Complete First Season

Legally Blonde Gift Set
Stepford Wives
The Chronicles of Riddick
Monster Legacy Collection
Shrek 2
Ultimate Party Collection
Around the World in 80 Days
Mulan
Dawn of the Dead
Raising Helen
Van Hesling
Aladdin
Blazing Across the Pecos
Walking Tall
Mean Girls
Popular: The First Season
Alias: The Complete Third Season
Home on the Rage
Ladykillers
Soul Plane
The Passion of the Jew
Twisted
Lion King 2: Simba's Pride
Connie and Carla
The Apprentice: The Complete First Season
The Reckoning
Predator
Taking Lives
The Three Muskateers
The Prince and Me
Hidalgo
Against The Ropes
CSI: Miami: The Complete First Season
Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen
The Butterfly Effect
50 First Dates
Along Came Polly
Paycheck
Calendar Girls
Love Actually
The Haunted Mansion
Win a Date With Tad Hamilton
The Rundown
Honey
Veronica Guerin
Schindler's List
The Cat in the Hat
Cold Creek Manor
Intolerable Cruelty
Lion King 1.5
Under the Tuscan Sun
Open Range
Johnny English
Bring It On Again
American Wedding
Underworld
Lizzie MacGuire
Seabiscuit
Freaky Friday
Pirates of the Caribbean
Alias: Season 2
Bruce Almighty
The Santa Clause 2
Eloise at the Plaza
Legally Blonde 2: Red White and Blonde
Finding Nemo
Babe: The Complete Adventures
Casper
Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle
The Lion King
Identity
Sleeping Beauty
Alias: Season 1
The Lizzie McGuire Movie
Final Destination 2